Pickles Pub Key West Menu (Update 2025)
From the Fryer
Gator Tail
Try it with our spicy chipotle sauce to kick it up a notch.
Conch Fritters
Served with our house-made jalapeno white sauce.
Chicken Fingers
Classic chicken tenders served with ranch, honey mustard or BBQ.
Fried Mozzarella
Battered and fried mozzarella paired with a savory marinara.
Fried Pickles
House specialty. Hand-cut pickle chips freshly battered and served with a side of boom boom ranch sauce.
Fried Shrimp
Served with hand-cut fries and spicy cilantro slaw.
Coconut Shrimp
Battered with fresh coconut. and served with hand-cut fries and spicy cilantro slaw.
Natty Boh Shrimp
Fresh peel & eat shrimp steamed with onion and old bay.
Shrimps
Loaded Tators
Loaded Fries
Hand cut fries topped with bacon, jalapeno, melted cheese and ranch.
Crabby Tots
Topped with our signature Maryland crab dip, smoked bacon, freshly chopped onion and melted Jack cheese.
Nachya Tots
Topped with lettuce, tomato, black beans, jalapenos and melted Jack cheese. Finished with boom boom sauce.
Feelin Crabby
Our signature Maryland crab dip served with toasted French bread.
Smoked Mahi
Topped with paprika, red onion & scallions. Served with jalapenos & tortilla chips.
French Onion
Butter and brown sugar sautee. Blended in our secret spice blend and whipped with sour cream & tortilla chips on all credit card bansactions.
Dips
Burgers & Handhelds
Chicken Chesapeke
Grilled chicken breast, homade crab dip and melted Jack cheese.
Shaved Beefer
Grilled sourdough stuffed with cilantro slaw, cheddar, sauteed onion & chipotle mayo.
Chicken Caesar
Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing. Grilled or baja chicken.
Boom Boom Burger
Sweet & spicy boom boom sauce, bacon & pepper Jack.
Nashville Hot Chicken
Pickle-brined chicken breast, lightly breaded and tossed in our homeade Nashville hot sauce.
The Hot One
Pepper Jack, homeade escabeche topped with Sriracha agave.
Bourbonzola
Bourbon-glazed onion, blue cheese crumble & BBQ sauce.
Philly Cheese
Sliced ribeye or chicken. Pepper, onion and melted provolone.
Pulled Pork
Slow-cooked pork with a pineapple BBQ sauce & American cheese.
The Big Kahuna
Grilled pinapple, bacon, cheddar and our sweet & spicy chili sauce.
The Hippie
Plant-based beyond burger.
Sizzlin Steak & Chicken Fajitas
Marinated in tequila with a blend of herbs and spices.
Gator Tacos
Served in a flour tortilla, on a bed of red cabbage and shredded carrot. Cotija cheese and your choice of jalapeno white sauce or spicy chipotle.
Hogfish Tacos
Served in a flour tortilla, on a bed of red cabbage and shredded carrot. Cotija cheese and your choice of jalapeno white sauce or spicy chipotle.
Shrimp Tacos
Served in a flour tortilla, on a bed of red cabbage and shredded carrot. Cotija cheese and your choice of jalapeno white sauce or spicy chipotle.
Big Ass Plate of Nachos
Piled high and topped with lettuce, tomato, black beans, jalapenos and melted Jack cheese. Ranch and boom boom sauce drizzle, add protein, add queso for an additional charge.
Build Your Own Burrito
White flour tortilla with your choice of cilantro lime rice, black beans, lettuce, tomato, pico, sour cream, guacamole, cheese, salsa, chicken steak, queso for an additional charge.
Tex-Mex
Tacos a la Cart
Soft Taco a la Cart
Soft flour tortilla, meat, cheese, lettuce and pico.
Fried & Crispy Taco a la Cart
Freshly fried crispy corn shell, meat, cheese, lettuce and pico.
Street Taco a la Cart
Corn tortilla, meat, fresh onion, cilantro and Cotija cheese.
Soft Taco Combo
Soft flour tortilla, meat, cheese, lettuce and pico.
Fried & Crispy Taco Combo
Freshly fried crispy corn shell, meat, cheese, lettuce and pico.
Street Taco Combo
Corn tortilla, meat, fresh onion, cilantro and Cotija cheese.
Tacos a la Cart Combo
10" Pizza
10" Lobster Pizza
Vodka sauce, fresh caught lobster tail and cheese.
10" Voo Doo Pizza
Blackened chicken, BBQ sauce, bacon, fresh jalapeno, mozzarella and blue cheese crumble.
10" Red Vine Margherita Pizza
Cherry tomato, fresh basil, mozzarella, Parmesan and balsalmic glaze.
10" Blackened Shrimp Basil Pizza
Garlic butter sauce, cherry tomato, mozzarella, fresh basil and balsalmic glaze.
10" Mac Attack Pizza
Ground beef, mac sauce, tomato, red onion, pickle, lettuce and Jack cheese.
10" Pickle Pizza
Garlic butter sauce, mozzarella, pickle chips, bacon and ranch drizzle.
10" Classic Pizza
MOzzarella and marinara.
10" Taco Pizza
Taco meat, pico, cheddar, mozzarella and sour cream.
10" Carnivore Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, ham and ground beef.
10" Calzone
Ricotta, mozzarella stuffed in pizza dough with your choice of up to 4 toppings.
Key West Chopped Salad
Grilled chicken, black beans, corn, green pepper, red onion, tomato, blue cheese, Parmesan and cilantro lime dressing.
Caesar Salad
Parmesan, Caesar dressing, croutons.
Blackened Shrimp Taco Salad
Corn, pico, cheese, tortilla strips and sour cream.
Aunt Kiels Chili
Served with cheese, tortilla chips and sour cream.
Pub Greens
Daily Specials
1/2 Nacho Monday Special
Taco Tuesday Special
1/2 tacos and domestic drafts.
Wing Wednesday Special
1/2 wings, pabst blue ribbon and fireball.
Cheeseburger Thursday Special
1/2 burgers and fresh squeezed crushed.
Pizza Party Friday Special
Cheese pizza and 1 topping.
1/2 Nacho with Drink Monday Special
Taco with Drink Tuesday Special
1/2 tacos and domestic drafts.
Wing with Drink Wednesday Special
1/2 wings, pabst blue ribbon and fireball.
Cheeseburger with Drink Thursday Special
1/2 burgers and fresh squeezed crushed.
Pizza Party with Drink Friday Special
Cheese pizza and 1 topping.
Daily Specials After 4 PM
Late Night Menu
Salsa Chips & Dip
Queso Chips & Dip
Fresh Guacamole Chips & Dip
Soft Pretzel Trio
4 stadium style pretzel logs paired with our French onion dip, feelin crabby dip and nacho cheese.
Wings
Street Tacos
Corn tortilla with your choice of meat, topped with fresh onion and cilantro.
Nachos
Topped with lettuce, tomato, black beans, jalapenos and melted Jack cheese. Ranch and boom boom sauce drizzle.